New or Changed Behavior with Editor Adapters
If you are updating code that was written against earlier versions of the Visual Studio core editor, and you plan to use the editor adapters (or shims) rather than using the new API, you should be aware of the following differences in the behavior of the editor adapters with respect to the previous core editor.
Features
Using SetSite()
You must call SetSite when you CoCreate text buffers, text views, and code windows before you perform any other operations on them. However, this is not necessary if you use the IVsEditorAdaptersFactoryService to create them, because this service's Create() methods themselves call SetSite.
Hosting IVsCodeWindow and IVsTextView in your own content
You can host both IVsCodeWindow and IVsTextView in your own content using either Win32 mode or WPF mode. However, you should keep in mind that there are some differences in the two modes.
Using Win32 and WPF versions of IVsCodeWindow
The editor code window is derived from WindowPane, which implements the older Win32 IVsWindowPane interface as well as the new WPF IVsUIElementPane interface. You can use the IVsWindowPane.CreatePaneWindow method to create an HWND-based hosting environment, or the IVsUIElementPane.CreateUIElementPane method to create a WPF hosting environment. The underlying editor always uses WPF, but you can create the kind of window pane that suits your hosting requirements if you are embedding this window pane directly into your own content.
Using Win32 and WPF versions of IVsTextView
You can set an IVsTextView to Win32 mode or WPF mode.
When an editor factory creates a text view, by default it is hosted inside an HWND, and GetWindowHandle returns an HWND. You should not use this mode to embed the editor inside a WPF control.
To set a text view to WPF mode, you must call Initialize and pass in VIF_NO_HWND_SUPPORT as one of the initialization flags in the InitView parameter. You can get the FrameworkElement by calling CreateUIElementPane.
WPF mode differs from Win32 mode in two ways. First, the text view can be hosted in a WPF context. You can access the WPF pane by casting the IVsTextView to IVsUIElementPane and calling GetUIObject. Second, GetWindowHandle still returns an HWND, but this HWND can be used only to check its position and set focus on it. You must not use this HWND to respond to a WM_PAINT message, because it will not affect how the editor paints the window. This HWND is present only to facilitate the transition to the new editor code by means of the adapters. It is highly recommended that you should not use VIF_NO_HWND_SUPPORT if your component requires an HWND to work, due to the limitations in the HWND returned from GetWindowHandle while in this mode.
Passing arrays as parameters in native code
There are many methods in the legacy editor API that have parameters that include an array and its count. Examples are:
If you are calling these methods in native code, you must pass in only one element at a time. If you pass in more than one element, the call will be rejected, due to problems with the primary interop implementation.
The problem is more complex with methods such as SetIgnoreMarkerTypes. Every time this method is called, it clears the previous list of ignored marker types, so it is not possible simply to call this method three times with three different marker types. The only remedy is to call this method only in managed code.
Threading
You should always call the buffer adapter from the UI thread. The buffer adapter is a managed object, which means that calling into it from managed code will bypass COM marshaling and your call will not automatically be marshaled to the UI thread. If you are calling the buffer adapter from a background thread, you must use Invoke or a similar method.
LockBuffer methods
All LockBuffer() methods are deprecated. Examples are:
Commit events
Commit events are not supported. Calling a method that advises for these events causes the method to return a failure code.
IVsPreliminaryTextChangeCommitEvents
IVsFinalTextChangeCommitEvents
IVsUndoRedoClusterWithCommitEvents
TextEditorEvents
The TextEditorEvents no longer fire on Commit(). Instead they fire on every text change.
Text Markers
You must call Invalidate on IVsTextMarker objects when you remove them. In previous versions, you needed only to release the markers.
Line numbers
For a variety of methods on IVsTextView and IVsTextViewEx, line numbers correspond to underlying buffer line numbers, not line numbers that factor in outlining and word-wrap, as in Visual Studio 2008.
The methods affected include the following (the list is not exhaustive):
Outlining
Clients of IVsHiddenTextSession will see only those outlining regions that were added using AddHiddenRegionsor AddHiddenRegionsEx. They will not see ad hoc regions, because they are not added through the editor adapters. Likewise, these clients will not see outlining regions added by languages (including C# and C++) that are using the new editor code rather than the editor adapters.
Line heights
In the new editor, text lines can have different heights, depending on the font size and possible line transforms that may move the line relative to other lines. The line height returned by methods such as GetLineHeight is the height of a line using the default font size with no line transforms applied. This height may or may not reflect the actual height of a line in the view.
Eventing and undo
In the new editor, the view continues to perform operations such as rendering and raising events continuously, even when an undo cluster is open. This behavior is different from that of legacy views, which did not perform those operations until after the closing of the undo cluster.
IntelliSense
- The UpdateTipWindow method will fail if you pass in a class that does not implement either IVsTextTipWindow2 or IVsMethodTipWindow3. Custom Win32 owner-drawn popups are no longer supported.
SmartTags
There is no adapter support for smart tags created with, IVsSmartTagData, IVsSmartTagTipWindow, and IVsSmartTagTipWindow2 interfaces.
DTE
IncrementalSearch is not implemented.
Unimplemented methods
Some methods have not been implemented on the text buffer adapter, text view adapter, and text layer adapter.
Interface |
Not implemented |
|---|---|
Reload(false) is not implemented. |
|
SetSubjectFromPrimaryBuffer is implemented in the adapters but ignored by the outlining UI. |
|
GetBannerAttr is implemented in the adapters but ignored by the outlining UI. |