Microsoft network server: Digitally sign communications (if client agrees)

 

Applies To: Windows Server 2003, Windows Vista, Windows XP, Windows Server 2008, Windows 7, Windows 8.1, Windows Server 2008 R2, Windows Server 2012 R2, Windows Server 2012, Windows 8

This security policy reference topic for the IT professional describes the best practices, location, values, policy management and security considerations for this policy setting.

Reference

The Server Message Block (SMB) protocol provides the basis for file and print sharing and many other networking operations, such as remote Windows administration. To prevent man-in-the-middle attacks that modify SMB packets in transit, the SMB protocol supports the digital signing of SMB packets. This policy setting determines whether SMB packet signing must be negotiated before further communication with the Server service is permitted.

Implementation of digital signatures in high-security networks helps to prevent the impersonation of client computers and servers, which is known as "session hijacking." But misuse of these policy settings is a common error that can cause data loss or problems with data access or security.

For this policy to take effect on computers running Windows 2000, client-side packet signing must also be enabled. To enable client-side SMB packet signing, set Microsoft network client: Digitally sign communications (if server agrees). Computers that have this policy set will not be able to communicate with computers that do not have server-side packet signing enabled. By default, server-side packet signing is enabled only on domain controllers running Windows 2000, Windows Server 2003, Windows Server 2008, and Windows Server 2008 R2. Server-side packet signing can be enabled on these computers by settingMicrosoft network server: Digitally sign communications (if client agrees).

If server-side SMB signing is required, a client computer will not be able to establish a session with that server, unless it has client-side SMB signing enabled. By default, client-side SMB signing is enabled on workstations, servers, and domain controllers. Similarly, if client-side SMB signing is required, that client computer will not be able to establish a session with servers that do not have packet signing enabled. By default, server-side SMB signing is enabled only on domain controllers.

If server-side SMB signing is enabled, SMB packet signing will be negotiated with client computers that have SMB signing enabled.

Using SMB packet signing can impose up to a 15 percent performance degradation on file service transactions.

There are three other policy settings that relate to packet-signing requirements for Server Message Block (SMB) communications:

• Microsoft network server: Digitally sign communications (always)

• Microsoft network client: Digitally sign communications (if server agrees)

• Microsoft network client: Digitally sign communications (always)

Possible values

• Enabled

• Disabled

• Not defined

Best practices

1. Configure the following security policy settings as follows:

   • Disable Microsoft Network Client: Digitally Sign Communications (Always).

   • Disable Microsoft Network Server: Digitally Sign Communications (Always).

   • Enable Microsoft Network Client: Digitally Sign Communications (If Server Agrees).

   • Enable Microsoft Network Server: Digitally Sign Communications (If Client Agrees).

2. Alternately, you can set all of these policy settings to Enabled, but enabling them can cause slower performance on client computers and prevent them from communicating with legacy SMB applications and operating systems.

Location

GPO_name\Computer Configuration\Windows Settings\Security Settings\Local Policies\Security Options

Default values

The following table lists the actual and effective default values for this policy. Default values are also listed on the policy’s property page.

Server type or GPO	Default value
Default Domain Policy	Not defined
Default Domain Controller Policy	Enabled
Stand-Alone Server Default Settings	Not defined
DC Effective Default Settings	Enabled
Member Server Effective Default Settings	Not defined
Client Computer Effective Default Settings	Disabled

Operating system version differences

There are no differences in this policy setting between operating systems beginning with Windows Server 2003.

Policy management

This section describes features and tools that are available to help you manage this policy.

Restart requirement

None. Changes to this policy become effective without a computer restart when they are saved locally or distributed through Group Policy.

Security considerations

This section describes how an attacker might exploit a feature or its configuration, how to implement the countermeasure, and the possible negative consequences of countermeasure implementation.

Vulnerability

Session hijacking uses tools that allow attackers who have access to the same network as the client computer or server to interrupt, end, or steal a session in progress. Attackers can potentially intercept and modify unsigned Server Message Block (SMB) packets and then modify the traffic and forward it so that the server might perform objectionable actions. Alternatively, the attacker could pose as the server or client computer after legitimate authentication and gain unauthorized access to data.

SMB is the resource-sharing protocol that is supported by many Windows operating systems. It is the basis of NetBIOS and many other protocols. SMB signatures authenticate users and the servers that host the data. If either side fails the authentication process, data transmission does not take place.

Countermeasure

Configure the settings as follows:

• Disable Microsoft Network Client: Digitally Sign Communications (Always).

• Disable Microsoft Network Server: Digitally Sign Communications (Always).

• Enable Microsoft Network Client: Digitally Sign Communications (If Server Agrees).

• Enable Microsoft Network Server: Digitally Sign Communications (If Client Agrees).

In highly secure environments we recommend that you configure all of these settings to Enabled. However, that configuration may cause slower performance on client computers and prevent communications with earlier SMB applications and operating systems.

Note

An alternative countermeasure that could protect all network traffic is to implement digital signatures with IPsec. There are hardware-based accelerators for IPsec encryption and signing that could be used to minimize the performance impact on the servers' CPUs. No such accelerators are available for SMB signing.

Potential impact

In the Windows Server 2008 R2, Windows Server 2008, Windows Server 2003, Windows 2000 Server, Windows 7, Windows Vista, Windows XP Professional, and Windows 2000 Professional operating systems, implementations of the SMB file and print-sharing protocol support mutual authentication. This prevents session hijacking attacks and supports message authentication to prevent man-in-the-middle attacks. SMB signing provides this authentication by placing a digital signature into each SMB, which is then verified by the client and the server.

Implementation of SMB signing may negatively affect performance because each packet must be signed and verified. If these settings are enabled on a server that is performing multiple roles, such as a small business server that is serving as a domain controller, file server, print server, and application server, performance may be substantially slowed. Additionally, if you configure computers to ignore all unsigned SMB communications, older applications and operating systems cannot connect. However, if you completely disable all SMB signing, computers are vulnerable to session-hijacking attacks.