How to Determine the Minimum Staging Area DFSR Needs for a Replicated Folder
Warren here again. This is a quick reference guide on how to calculate the minimum staging area needed for DFSR to function properly. Values lower than these may cause replication to go slowly or stop altogether. Keep in mind these are minimums only. When considering staging area size, remember this: the bigger the staging area the better, up to the size of the Replicated Folder. See the section “How to determine if you have a staging area problem” and the blog posts linked at the end of this article for more details on why it is important to have a properly sized staging area.
Update: Warren is very persuasive! We now have a hotfix to help you with calculating staging sizes. https://support.microsoft.com/kb/2607047
Rules of thumb
Windows Server 2003 R2 – The staging area quota must be as large as the 9 largest files in the Replicated Folder
Windows Server 2008 and 2008 R2 – The staging area quota must be as large as the 32 largest files in the Replicated Folder
Initial Replication will make much more use of the staging area than day-to-day replication. Setting the staging area higher than the minimum during initial replication is strongly encouraged if you have the drive space available
Where do I get PowerShell?
PowerShell is included on Windows 2008 and higher. You must install PowerShell on Windows Server 2003. You can download PowerShell for Windows 2003 here.
How do you find these X largest files?
Use a PowerShell script to find the 32 or 9 largest files and determine how many gigabytes they add up to (thanks to Ned Pyle for the PowerShell commands). I am actually going to present you with three PowerShell scripts. Each is useful on its own; however, number 3 is the most useful.
1. Run:
Get-ChildItem c:\temp -recurse | Sort-Object length -descending | select-object -first 32 | ft name,length -wrap –auto
This command will return the file names and the size of the files in bytes. Useful if you want to know what 32 files are the largest in the Replicated Folder so you can “visit” their owners.
2. Run:
Get-ChildItem c:\temp -recurse | Sort-Object length -descending | select-object -first 32 | measure-object -property length –sum
This command will return the total number of bytes of the 32 largest files in the folder without listing the file names.
3. Run:
$big32 = Get-ChildItem c:\temp -recurse | Sort-Object length -descending | select-object -first 32 | measure-object -property length –sum
$big32.sum /1gb
This command will get the total number of bytes of 32 largest files in the folder and do the math to convert bytes to gigabytes for you. This command is two separate lines. You can paste both them into the PowerShell command shell at once or run them back to back.
Manual Walkthrough
To demonstrate the process and hopefully increase understanding of what we are doing, I am going to manually step through each part.
Running command 1 will return results similar to the output below. This example only uses 16 files for brevity. Always use 32 for Windows 2008 and later operating systems and 9 for Windows 2003 R2
Example Data returned by PowerShell
Name Length File5.zip 10286089216 archive.zip 6029853696 BACKUP.zip 5751522304 file9.zip 5472683008 MENTOS.zip 5241586688 File7.zip 4321264640 file2.zip 4176765952 frd2.zip 4176765952 BACKUP.zip 4078994432 File44.zip 4058424320 file11.zip 3858056192 Backup2.zip 3815138304 BACKUP3.zip 3815138304 Current.zip 3576931328 Backup8.zip 3307488256 File999.zip 3274982400
How to use this data to determine the minimum staging area size:
- Name = Name of the file.
- Length = bytes
- One Gigabyte = 1073741824 Bytes
First, you need to sum the total number of bytes. Next divide the total by 1073741824. I suggest using Excel or your spreadsheet of choice to do the math.
Example
From the example above the total number of bytes = 75241684992. To get the minimum staging area quota needed I need to divide 75241684992 by 1073741824.
75241684992 / 1073741824 = 70.07 GB
Based on this data I would set my staging area to 71 GB if I round up to the nearest whole number.
Real World Scenario:
While a manual walkthrough is interesting it is likely not the best use of your time to do the math yourself. To automate the process, use command 3 from the examples above. The results will look like this
Using the example command 3 without any extra effort except for rounding to the nearest whole number, I can determine that I need a 6 GB staging area quota for d:\docs.
Do I Need to Reboot or Restart the Service for the Changes to be Picked Up?
Changes to the staging area quota do not require a reboot or restart of the service to take effect. You will need to wait on AD replication and DFSR’s AD polling cycle for the changes to be applied.
How to determine if you have a staging area problem
You detect staging area problems by monitoring for specific events IDs on your DFSR servers. The list of events is 4202, 4204, 4206, 4208 and 4212. The texts of these events are listed below. It is important to distinguish between 4202 and 4204 and the other events. It is possible to log a high number of 4202 and 4204 events under normal operating conditions. Think of 4202 and 4204 events as being analogous to taking your pulse whereas 4206, 4208 and 4212 are like chest pains. I explain below how to interpret your 4202 and 4204 events below.
Staging Area Events
Event ID: 4202
Severity: WarningThe DFS Replication service has detected that the staging space in use for the replicated folder at local path (path) is above the high watermark. The service will attempt to delete the oldest staging files. Performance may be affected.
Event ID: 4204
Severity: InformationalThe DFS Replication service has successfully deleted old staging files for the replicated folder at local path (path). The staging space is now below the high watermark.
Event ID: 4206
Severity: WarningThe DFS Replication service failed to clean up old staging files for the replicated folder at local path (path). The service might fail to replicate some large files and the replicated folder might get out of sync. The service will automatically retry staging space cleanup in (x) minutes. The service may start cleanup earlier if it detects some staging files have been unlocked.
Event ID: 4208
Severity: WarningThe DFS Replication service detected that the staging space usage is above the staging quota for the replicated folder at local path (path). The service might fail to replicate some large files and the replicated folder might get out of sync. The service will attempt to clean up staging space automatically.
Event ID: 4212
Severity: ErrorThe DFS Replication service could not replicate the replicated folder at local path (path) because the staging path is invalid or inaccessible.
What is the difference between 4202 and 4208?
Events 4202 and 4208 have similar text; i.e. DFSR detected the staging area usage exceeds the high watermark. The difference is that 4208 is logged after staging area cleanup has run and the staging quota is still exceeded. 4202 is a normal and expected event whereas 4208 is abnormal and requires intervention.
How many 4202, 4204 events are too many?
There is no single answer to this question. Unlike 4206, 4208 or 4212 events, which are always bad and indicate action is needed, 4202 and 4204 events occur under normal operating conditions. Seeing many 4202 and 4204 events may indicate a problem. Things to consider:
- Is the Replicated Folder (RF) logging 4202 performing initial replication? If so, it is normal to log 4202 and 4204 events. You will want to keep these to down to as few as possible during Initial Replication by providing as much staging area as possible
- Simply checking the total number of 4202 events is not sufficient. You have to know how many were logged per RF. If you log twenty 4202 events for one RF in a 24 hour period that is high. However if you have 20 Replicated Folders and there is one event per folder, you are doing well.
- You should examine several days of data to establish trends.
I usually counsel customers to allow no more than one 4202 event per Replicated Folder per day under normal operating conditions. “Normal” meaning no Initial Replication is occurring. I base this on the reasoning that:
- Time spent cleaning up the staging area is time spent not replicating files. Replication is paused while the staging area is cleared.
- DFSR benefits from a full staging area using it for RDC and cross-file RDC or replicating the same files to other members
- The more 4202 and 4204 events you log the greater the odds you will run into the condition where DFSR cannot clean up the staging area or will have to prematurely purge files from the staging area.
- 4206, 4208 and 4212 events are, in my experience, always preceded and followed by a high number of 4202 and 4204 events.
While allowing for only one 4202 event per RF per day is conservative it greatly decreases your odds of running into staging area problems and better utilizes your DFSR server’s resources for the intended purpose of replicating files.
More Information
Warren “way over my Oud quota” Williams
Comments
Anonymous
July 13, 2011
The comment has been removedAnonymous
July 13, 2011
Shorter still: (gci d:docs -r|sort length -des|select -f 32|measure length -s).sum/1gb Rounded: "{0:N2}" -f ((gci d:docs -r|sort length -des|select -f 32|measure length -s).sum/1gb) PS C:> "(gci d:docs -r|sort length -des|select -f 32|measure length -s).sum/1gb".Length 72 PS C:> '"{0:N2}" -f ((gci d:docs -r|sort length -des|select -f 32|measure length -s).sum/1gb)'.Length 86 PS C:> "(get-childitem d:docs -recurse | sort-object length -descending | select-object -first 32 | measure-object -property length -sum).sum /1gb".Length 139Anonymous
July 13, 2011
Show off! :-D Thanks Craig.Anonymous
July 13, 2011
The comment has been removedAnonymous
July 14, 2011
Well, even shorter one: (ls d:docs -r|sort le* -des)[1..32]|%{$b+=$_.length/1gb};$b —courtesy of Vasily GusevAnonymous
July 14, 2011
Except that: Vasily's new one is saying my 32 largest files total 4.72 GB, instead of 5.52 GB which is the truth. There's a glitch in there somewhere. And while Craig's first one calculates my largest 32 size correctly, the next three appear to say I need 72GB, 86GB, or 139GB. Adding Craig, Artem, and Vasily to the list of people that I never want to get stuck standing next to at a dinner party, btw. :-PAnonymous
July 14, 2011
Yep, forgot the largetst file :) (ls c:n -r|sort le* -des)[0..31]|%{$b+=$_.length/1gb};$b this shows the same result as Craig's (if you run it again do “Remove-Variable -Name "b"” first). and, okay, the next party we'll let you go ahead of us, if you wish to leave in the middle of the talk :)Anonymous
July 21, 2011
The comment has been removedAnonymous
August 12, 2011
huh... does it mean, that if you have not to much space left there is no way to use DFS? what about situation - you keep some large image/backup files - i.e. 2oGB each. 32x2oGB is 64oGB just for staging!! this suppose to be some brilliant solution and more i read more i am terrified - it's better to use robocopy which do not need any space at all. why is that number growing - from 9 to 32? developement of the protocol should optimize it and it seems that it has bigger requirements [means - is worse]. summing up - DFSR is not cheap solution for SMB/midbiz - and rather enterprise only solution to be used on huge disk spaces - unless you use it just for small files [i.e. office] ):Anonymous
August 12, 2011
The comment has been removedAnonymous
August 06, 2014
The comment has been removedAnonymous
September 21, 2014
How to Determine the Minimum Staging Area DFSR Needs for a Replicated Folder - Ask the Directory Services Team - Site Home - TechNet BlogsAnonymous
May 27, 2015
The comment has been removed