macOS Catalina Notarization and the impact on .NET downloads and projects
Beginning with macOS Catalina (version 10.15), all software built after June 1, 2019, and distributed with Developer ID, must be notarized. This requirement applies to the .NET runtime, .NET SDK, and software created with .NET. This article describes the common scenarios you may face with .NET and macOS notarization.
Installing .NET
The installers for .NET (both runtime and SDK) have been notarized since February 18, 2020. Prior released versions aren't notarized. You can manually install a non-notarized version of .NET by first downloading the installer, and then using the sudo installer command with the downloaded installer.
Native appHost
When your app is compiled, an appHost, which is a native Mach-O executable, is produced. This executable is usually invoked by .NET when your project compiles, publishes, or is run with the dotnet run command. The non-appHost version of your app is a dll file that can be invoked by the dotnet <app.dll> command.
When run locally, the SDK signs the apphost using ad hoc signing, which allows the app to run locally. When distributing your app, you'll need to properly sign your app according to Apple guidance.
You can also distribute your app without the apphost and rely on users to run your app using dotnet. To turn off appHost generation, add the UseAppHost boolean setting in the project file and set it to false. You can also toggle the appHost with the -p:UseAppHost parameter on the command line for the specific dotnet command you run:
Project file
<PropertyGroup> <UseAppHost>false</UseAppHost> </PropertyGroup>Command-line parameter
dotnet run -p:UseAppHost=false
An appHost is required when you publish your app self-contained and you cannot disable it.
For more information about the UseAppHost setting, see MSBuild properties for Microsoft.NET.Sdk.
Context of the appHost
When the appHost is enabled in your project, and you use the dotnet run command to run your app, the app is invoked in the context of the appHost and not the default host (the default host is the dotnet command). If the appHost is disabled in your project, the dotnet run command runs your app in the context of the default host. Even if the appHost is disabled, publishing your app as self-contained generates an appHost executable, and users use that executable to run your app. Running your app with dotnet <filename.dll> invokes the app with the default host, the shared runtime.
When an app using the appHost is invoked, the certificate partition accessed by the app is different from the notarized default host. If your app must access the certificates installed through the default host, use the dotnet run command to run your app from its project file, or use the dotnet <filename.dll> command to start the app directly.
More information about this scenario is provided in the ASP.NET Core and macOS and certificates section.
ASP.NET Core, macOS, and certificates
.NET provides the ability to manage certificates in the macOS Keychain with the System.Security.Cryptography.X509Certificates class. Access to the macOS Keychain uses the applications identity as the primary key when deciding which partition to consider. For example, unsigned applications store secrets in the unsigned partition, but signed applications store their secrets in partitions only they can access. The source of execution that invokes your app decides which partition to use.
.NET provides three sources of execution: appHost, default host (the dotnet command), and a custom host. Each execution model may have different identities, either signed or unsigned, and has access to different partitions within the Keychain. Certificates imported by one mode may not be accessible from another. For example, the notarized versions of .NET have a default host that is signed. Certificates are imported into a secure partition based on its identity. These certificates aren't accessible from a generated appHost, as the appHost is ad-hoc signed.
Another example, by default, ASP.NET Core imports a default SSL certificate through the default host. ASP.NET Core applications that use an appHost won't have access to this certificate and will receive an error when .NET detects the certificate isn't accessible. The error message provides instructions on how to fix this problem.
If certificate sharing is required, macOS provides configuration options with the security utility.
For more information on how to troubleshoot ASP.NET Core certificate issues, see Enforce HTTPS in ASP.NET Core.
Default entitlements
.NET's default host (the dotnet command) has a set of default entitlements. These entitlements are required for proper operation of .NET. It's possible that your application may need additional entitlements, in which case you'll need to generate and use an appHost and then add the necessary entitlements locally.
Default set of entitlements for .NET:
com.apple.security.cs.allow-jitcom.apple.security.cs.allow-unsigned-executable-memorycom.apple.security.cs.allow-dyld-environment-variablescom.apple.security.cs.disable-library-validation
Notarize a .NET app
If you want your application to run on macOS Catalina (version 10.15) or higher, you'll want to notarize your app. The appHost you submit with your application for notarization should be used with at least the same default entitlements for .NET Core.
