Jaa

To DC or not to DC that is the question.....

  • Artikkeli

Urban Legend..."Did you know that it is impossible to have additional Domain Controllers in a Small Business Server Domain?"

This is in fact a myth as long as a few conditions are met. 

  1. The SBS 2003 computer must be a domain controller that is installed on the root of the domain.
  2. The SBS 2003 computer must hold all the Flexible Single Master Operation (FSMO) roles.
  3. The SBS 2003 computer must be a global catalog server and must be the licensing server.
  4. There must not be any existing domain trusts or child domains.
  5. Only one SBS server can exist on the domain. If SBS 2003 is installed, no other SBS 2003 or 2000 server can be installed on the same domain 

What The heck is a FSMO role... see https://support.microsoft.com/kb/324801 for a brief description.  

So why would I need an additional Domain Controller anyway? Along with the benefits an additional domain controller can add to a network by it's nature, it also has a copy of your Active Directory data.

Here's the scenario: I have an SBS server, 1 additional domain controller and 35 testy users.... ;)

A storm is rolling across the plains... Lightening strikes the local electrical company, something happens with the local backup power supply for the network and all the servers come crashing down. With fingers crossed you re-start all of the network boxes. Client boxes restart fine......including the V.P. that always wants to keep 10gb of email - :)! You walk back into the server room - to find the additional DC has recovered fine, but after several calls you find that the motherboard on the SBS server is going to need to be replaced! 

Uhh-ooh new hardware....yikes...now were looking at downtime but little do I realize that this is the least of my worries! How is new hardware going to react with my current set of backups for the SBS server? Am I going to have to reinstall the domain? Whats going to happen to all of the current desktop profiles for my 35 testy users? Is Exchange going to work? Are my backups any good? Can I restore the data? How long is this going to take?? Man i'm in trouble...........right? No not really, as long as you have valid back-up of your data, and an additional, current, functional, domain controller in your domain to help with you Active Directory information.  

Even though you have lost your SBS server, fortunately for you, you still have a current DC from you old domain. An existing domain controller = an existing domain. So how would I install an SBS server into an existing domain? Fortunately there is an article available "How to install Small Business Server into an existing Active Directory domain" https://support.microsoft.com/kb/884453/en-us . This article walks you through how to reinstall SBS on to new hardware, while still having the ability to work around the necessary boundries of SBS.

Second DC.........Just say yes!

>edwalt

Comments

  • Anonymous
    May 04, 2007
    True. I have more than one DC with my current server setup. However, you can't have multiple forests and your server can't belong to more than one forest with the Windows Small Business Server. Those are big-time drawbacks.  The catch is the liscensing gets expensive for the add on pack that allows you to have these capablilites. These capabilites are not limited on the standard edition of Windows Server 2003.  It would be nice if they would throw that in ... but I guess that is why the Small Business Server is priced so low.

  • Anonymous
    February 29, 2008
    LLlR9n r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 01, 2008
    mtYdSr r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 06, 2008
    XZRKj0 r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read, man!

  • Anonymous
    March 06, 2008
    pi3XeL r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 07, 2008
    fnDlOC r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 07, 2008
    bFQg0J r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 07, 2008
    AZUnJ0 r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 07, 2008
    YkoiG3 r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 08, 2008
    gOsX9m r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!

  • Anonymous
    March 08, 2008
    YhG1z9 r u crazzy? I told u! I can't read!