Freigeben über

Which keyboard is the fastest? QWERTY Shootout!

  • Artikel

Well over the Christmas period I had an idea to test which devices were the fastest for keyboard entry. 

As the number of Windows Mobile based QWERTY based devices continues to increase I thought it would be interesting to see how each device compared in terms of entering a paragraph of text.

I used the Frequently used words test from:  https://www.powertyping.com/typing_test/typing_test.shtml

The paragraph contains 81 frequently used words that people type regularly - the text is below:

could no make than first been its who now people my made over did down only way find use may water long little very after words called just where most know get through back much before go good new write our used me man too any day same right look think also around another came come work three word must because does part even place well such here take why things help put years different away again off went old number

So over the break I borrowed a few devices from friends and timed entering the text on each device!  I picked the K-Jam, HP 6500, Universal as well as a couple of other non Windows Mobile devices.  The Treo 650 as it's the same form factor as the Windows Mobile Treo 700w device, the Nokia 9300 as my Nordic friends are always telling me what a great device this is and finally the Blackberry 7290 device.

 

Device Time Mistakes
Laptop 01:02 6
Imate K-Jam 01:53 3
Blackberry 01:53 5
Treo 650w 01:53 4
HP 6500 01:54 7
Universal 01:55 10
Nokia 9300 02:08 10
Orange C600 02:15 10

My conclusions from the test are as follows:

  • Obviously the laptop keyboard is the fastest - some 51 seconds quicker than a mobile device.  I can type at 94 WPM (Words per Minute) which is pretty quick :)
  • What suprised me was that T9 input was only 20 seconds slower so just over 16% slower than using a keyboard.  I am a faster T9'er though so other people may be much slower!
  • The K-Jam, Blackberry (7290), Treo 650 and HP 6500 were all about the same time.
  • The Nokia 9300 - I found the keyboard really difficult to use as it didn't give me good postive feedback when I pressed keys and my hands were aching after entering the single paragraph of text.

Comments

  • Anonymous
    January 06, 2006
    A bit surprising that the Universal scores so low, I really like the keyboard on it and find it quite natural to use.

    As for the T9'ing, you're not natural mate, I find it so frustrating since moving to PPC PE and having the stylus.

    Any chance you'd add a couple of comparisons of using the soft keyboard and transcriber?

  • Anonymous
    January 06, 2006
    You really need to repeat the tests a number of times for those mistake figures to have any meaning. The poisson error on each of those individually is massive, making the data meaningless.

  • Anonymous
    January 10, 2006
    Jason - you and your friends really need to get out more!

    ;-)

  • Anonymous
    August 20, 2007
    Jenneth over on Gear Diary did some great testing on which Smartphone Keyboard is fastest for entering

  • Anonymous
    August 20, 2007
    Jenneth over on Gear Diary did some great testing on which Smartphone Keyboard is fastest for entering

  • Anonymous
    August 20, 2007
    Jenneth over on Gear Diary did some great testing on which Smartphone Keyboard is fastest for entering

  • Anonymous
    October 15, 2008
    PocketNow produced this great Keyboard comparison which compares the time it takes to input a common

  • Anonymous
    October 15, 2008
    The comment has been removed

  • Anonymous
    January 09, 2009
    PingBack from http://www.mrmobileblog.com/2008/10/15/keyboard-comparison/

  • Anonymous
    January 09, 2009
    PingBack from http://www.mrmobileblog.com/2007/08/20/gear-diary-smartphone-keyboard-shootout/